Inadequate |
Developing |
Proficient |
Notes |
IDENTIFICATION 0 |
3 |
5 |
|
Does not include all identifying information. Does not include printout or screenshot or resource. |
Either does not include all identifying information, or does not include printout or screenshot of resource. |
Identifies project with student name, section number, and research focus topic. States the title and type of resource evaluated. Includes print-out of article, screenshot of website, excerpt of e-book, or actual book. |
|
CITATION 0 |
3 |
5 |
|
Does not identify proper citation style and does not include complete citation (a website URL is not a complete citation). |
Either identifies a citation style that is inappropriate to major or does not format citation correctly. |
Identifies citation style that is appropriate to major, and formats bibliographic citation appropriately. |
|
DELIVERY 0 |
6 |
10 |
|
Attire is non-professional (jeans, t-shirt, or sneakers). Verbal presentation is unpracticed or disorganized. |
Either attire is non-professional (jeans, t-shirt, or sneakers) or verbal presentation is unpracticed or disorganized. |
Professionally and neatly attired in business casual slacks or skirt, shirt, and dress shoes. Well-spoken, good eye contact, and engaging verbal presentation. |
|
DISCOVERY 0 |
6 |
10 |
|
Does not identify COM 2012 lesson nor steps taken to find resource. |
Either does not identify COM 2012 lesson, or does not describe steps taken to find resource. |
States in which COM 2012 lesson the resource was discovered, and explains steps taken to discover it. |
|
ACADEMIC USAGE 0 |
6 |
10 |
|
Does not explain how the resource might be used in academic coursework or how students would benefit from the resource. |
Either does not explain how the resource might be used in academic coursework, or does not explain how students would benefit from the resource. |
Explains how the resource might be used in academic coursework, specifically in relation to research focus topic. Identifies FIT courses, programs, and students that would benefit from the resource. |
|
ORGANIZATION 0 |
6 |
10 |
|
Does not explain the organization, sections, special features, and search strategies. |
Does not sufficiently explain the organization, sections, special features, and search strategies or does not address one or more of these. |
Identifies and explains the organization, sections, and special features within the resource. Explains how the five search strategies apply (or why they do not). |
|
EVALUATION - WHO 0 |
12 |
20 |
|
Does not include the authors’, organizations’, or publisher’s credentials, reliability, and reputation, or the accuracy and quality of content and cited sources. |
Does not sufficiently discuss the authors’, organizations’, or publisher’s credentials, reliability, and reputation, or the accuracy and quality of content and cited sources. |
Explains the authors’ and organizations’ authority, including credentials, degrees, and qualifications. Discusses the publisher’s/sponsor’s reliability and reputation. Evaluates the accuracy and quality of content and cited sources. |
|
EVALUATION - WHY 0 |
12 |
20 |
|
Does not state the purpose of the resource, its subject coverage, bias/slant/agenda or lack thereof, depth of coverage and comprehensiveness, and the intended and potential audience. |
Erroneously or insufficiently states the purpose of the resource, its subject coverage, bias/slant/agenda or lack thereof, depth of coverage and comprehensiveness, or the intended and potential audience. |
States, in 25 words or less, the purpose of the resource. Briefly discusses subject coverage. Evaluates bias/slant/agenda or lack thereof. Explains depth of coverage and comprehensiveness. Identifies the intended and potential audience. |
|
EVALUATION - WHEN 0 |
6 |
10 |
|
Omits pertinent dates, date coverage, and justification of timeliness. |
Omits pertinent date or date coverage, or does not explain their omission or timeliness. |
Includes creation, acceptance, publishing, and update dates or explains their omission. Discusses date coverage of content. Justifies resource date if it is not current. |
|
Totals: 0 |
60 |
100 |
|