SOCI 3020 Social Research Methods Research Project – Source Evaluation Rubric | |||||
Criteria | Expert(A) | Proficient (A- to B) | Apprentice(B- to C) | Novice(C to D) |
SCORE |
SCHOLARLY articles (4 points possible) Based on Ulrichs classification of journal as “academic/scholarly”. |
ALL of the 4 required articles are from scholarly journals | AT LEAST 3 are from scholarly journals | AT LEAST 2 are from scholarly journals | LESS THAN 2 are from scholarly journals | |
EMPIRICAL articles (4 points possible) Based on students’ paper discussion and/or article abstract. |
ALL of the 4 required articles are empirical analyses | AT LEAST 3 are empirical analyses | AT LEAST 2 are empirical analyses | LESS THAN 2 are empirical analyses | |
RELEVANCE of articles (4 points possible) Based on students’ paper discussion and/or article abstract. |
It is readily apparent how ALL of the 4 required articles relate to and inform his/her own research. | It is readily apparent how AT LEAST 3 relate to and inform his/her own research. | It is readily apparent how AT LEAST 2 relate to and inform his/her own research. | It is readily apparent how LESS THAN 2 relate to and inform his/her own research. |