Book Club - iSchool Student - Jenifer Arnold and Denice Buchanan

Indicators	Beginning	Developing	Exemplary	Data Source
Section 1
Speaking Clearly	0-15% of club members speak clearly, distinctly, are poised and confident during club discussions.	16-89% of club members speak clearly, distinctly, are poised and confident during club discussions.	90-97% of club members speak clearly, distinctly, are poised and confident during club discussions (note: if there are students who are too shy to talk and voice opinions during club meetings, they should not be forced to do so).	Observation/note taking during meetings
Elaborate Statements	0-10% of club members elaborate and back up their ideas and opinions with evidence	11-75% of club members elaborate and back up their ideas and opinions with evidence	76-97% of club members elaborate and back up their ideas and opinions with evidence	Observation/note taking during meetings
Peer Prospective	0-15% of club members invite and acknowledge comments from others and recognize differing opinions	16-89% of club members invite and acknowledge comments from others and recognize differing opinions	90-97% of club members invite and acknowledge comments from others and recognize differing opinions	Observation/note taking during meetings
Section 2
Active Listening	0-5% of club members are active listeners, and allow their peers to speak one at a time	6-79% of club members are active listeners, and allow their peers to speak one at a time	80-100% of club members are active listeners, and allow their peers to speak one at a time	Observation/note taking during meetings
Questions to Peers	0-5% of club members ask their peers appropriate questions using kind language and correct context	6-89% of club members ask their peers appropriate questions using kind language and correct context	90-100% of club members ask their peers appropriate questions using kind language and correct context	Observation/note taking during meetings
Connection to Character	0-39% of club members express feeling similarly to characters in certain situations	40-79% of club members express feeling similarly to characters in certain situations	80-100% of club members express feeling similarly to characters in certain situations	Observation/note taking during meetings
Connection to Real World Situations	0-20% of club members understand how empathy can create a better school and social environment	26-94% of club members understand how empathy can create a better school and social environment	95-100% of club members understand how empathy can create a better school and social environment	Observation/note taking during meetings Informal Interviews / Casual Conversation